Here is another review from the Journal of Writing Assessment’s archives:
Please read Susan Callahan’s review: “Testing the tests” from Volume 2 Number 1 of the Journal of Writing Assessment from Spring 2005.
Callahan reviews George Hillock’s The testing trap: How state writing assessments control learning. New York: Teachers College Press, Pub Date: April 2002, 240 pages Paperback: $23.95, ISBN: 0807742295 Cloth: $54, ISBN: 0807742309